This week’s Writers’ Block tackles a subject that has a lot of debate. Who is the greatest QB in NFL history?
The writers of Sports Unbiased were tasked with coming up with their top-5 NFL QBs of All-Time. The criteria they used to determine this was up to them – did winning Super Bowls matter or was it all about the numbers? No matter the criteria, the writers all voted and at the end 13 quarterbacks were listed.
The votes were tallied and the points counted (five points for a first place vote, four for second, down to one for first) and we ended up with the QBs being ranked 1 through 12 (there was one tie!).
The writers taking part this week were: Rich Stowe, Brian Podoll, Jerome Gourdine, Derek McVay, Adam Solowiei, Kimani Gregoire, Wesley Dotson, Nate Gerst, Mike Santangelo, Sammie Wright, and a special guest appearance by Matt Strobl.
One QB was ranked on all the ballots, and there was a mix of “old school,” current, and ones you’ll remember from your youth.
At the end of the rankings, be sure to vote in the poll for your top-5 QBs of all-time and be sure to comment to let us know what we did right or wrong and anything else you may want to tell us.
Up next: Number 12